A Study of State-Funded Community Networks in Indiana:

Final Report

October 1998

Submitted to the Indiana Department of Education
Center for School Improvement and Performance

Howard Rosenbaum
Kim Gregson
hrosenba@indiana.edu
kgregson@indiana.edu


Appendix B: Interview and Survey Instrument

A Study of State-Funded Community Networks in Indiana

Community Network Board Member Survey

School of Library and Information Science
Indiana University

Funded by the Indiana Department of Education

August 1997

Dr. Howard Rosenbaum Ms. Kim Gregson

Purpose: The main objective of this survey is to gather data about the current state of state-funded community networks (CNs) in Indiana. The survey will be used to develop an inventory of the resources and services made available through the CNs and to collect management information, including statements of local goals, planning, and methods of evaluation. Information will be collected about the successes, challenges, and failures faced by CNs in the last year.

This information will also enable the researchers to assess the cooperative strategies currently used by existing CNs, critically examine the means by which potential users and content providers can be made aware of the value of community networking, and focus on the public education and public library components of community networking.

Your cooperation is essential in this study. We hope that you will take the time to fill out and use the enclosed envelope to return this survey; you may also fax the survey to 812.855.6166 if this is more convenient. The data collected in this survey will be aggregated for reporting purposes, so individual responses will be anonymous and will remain confidential.

We would appreciate the return of the completed survey by Friday, October 4, 1997.

Questions regarding this survey should be addressed to:

Dr. Howard Rosenbaum
<hrosenba@indiana.edu>
Main Library 011
School of Library and Information Science
10th and Jordan
Indiana University
Bloomington, Indiana 47405-1801
821.855.3250 (Voice)
812.855.6166 (Fax)

A. The Community Network Board of Directors:

1. How many Board members do you have? ____

a. What sectors of the community are represented on the board?

__ K-12 __ Private citizen __ Public library
__ Local business __ Local government __ Local university/college
__ Other (please describe):

b. How are candidates recruited for the Board?

c. How many Board meetings were held last year? _____ How many did you attend? _____

2. Which of the following best describes the Board's decision making process?

__ Robert's Rules of Order __ Consensus building
__ Majority voting __ Other (please describe):

3.In your opinion, what are the three most important decisions the Board made in the last year?

B. The CN and the community

4.How satisfied are you with the current relationship between the CN and the community (Circle one)?

Very unsatisfied MoveMoveMoveMove!!! Neutral Very satisfied
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

a. Briefly describe the relationship between the CN and the community

b. How does the CN strengthen the "sense of community"?

c. What has the community done to support the CN?

d. What are the measures that you look for to indicate the impact the CN is having on the community?

5.How many users do you have?

Individual _____ K-12 (teachers, staff) _____ Business _____
Public library (librarians) _____ Govt/non-profits _____
Total number (if you can't break them out into categories) _____

a. Briefly describe your typical individual users

b. Why are they using the system?

c. How many users do you gain from month to month? ____

d. How many users do you lose from month to month? ____

1. Why do they leave the CN?
e. How do you communicate with your users (Check all that apply)?

__ Email __ Newsletter __ Web page announcements
__ Local media __ Bill insert __ Other (please specify)

f. Which of the following describe your typical communications with your users (Check all that apply)?

__ Feedback about current and proposed content
__ Soliciting information about what the resources and services they want
__ Feedback about how they think the CN is doing
__ Information about power outages, downtime and maintenance
__ Other (please describe):

6. Who develops content for the CN? (Check all that apply)

__ Board Members __ Subcontractors
__ CN members __ Non-members

a. Have you funded content development? Yes ___ No ___

1. If yes, briefly describe the process (competitive grants...)

2. What limitations did funders place on you (in the AI money for example) in the type of content that you could pay to have developed?

7. Do you have any paying advertisers or sponsors on your site? Yes ___ No ___

If no, skip to Question 8

a. How did you set your rates?

b. What are your rates for different sized businesses?

c. What are your rates for profit/non-profit organizations?

d. What are your rates for companies in your area vs. outside of the area?

e. Do you have any restrictions about who may advertise on or sponsor your CN? Yes ___ No ___

1. If yes, who may not advertise or provide sponsorship?

f. Do you have any restrictions about advertising or sponsorship content? Yes ___ No ___

1. If yes, what are they?

2. Do you provide statistics to the businesses about users or about usage, such as the number of hits on their page each month? Yes ___ No ___

g. Have any businesses stopped running their advertising or sponsorship? Yes ___ No ___

1. If yes, why?

8. How are you promoting and marketing the CN? (Check all that apply)?

__Word of mouth __ Press releases __ Newspaper advertising
__ Radio advertising __ Organizational newsletters __ Direct mail
__ Appearance at public events (fairs, festivals, demos) __ Other (please describe):

a. In your opinion, how successful are these efforts (Circle one)?

Very unsuccessful MoveMoveMoveMove!!! No Effect Very successful
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

9. Please describe the relationship between the CN and the local schools (in the space below)

a. What types of programs is the CN running with the schools?

b. How many teachers have been trained how to use the features of the CN? ___

c. How many students have been trained? ___

10. Please describe the relationship between the CN and the local public libraries (in the space below)

a. What types of programs is the CN running with the libraries?

b. How many librarians have been trained how to use the features of the CN? ___

c. How many library patrons have been trained? ___

11. What other organizations/companies/groups in the community work with the CN? (Please list)

a. How do these organizations/companies/groups use the CN

12. Do you use volunteers? Yes ___ No __

If yes, please answer (a) to (c); if no, skip to (d)

a. How many? ___

b. What are their main tasks?

c. How do you recruit them?

d. Please explain why you do not use volunteers

C. Your CN (Goals, resources and services, costs)

13.In your opinion, what were the three most important challenges the CN faced in the last year? (List below)

a. How did you resolve them?

b. In your opinion, what is the CN's biggest challenge in the next 12 months?

14.In your opinion, what are the three most important successes accomplished by the CN in the last year

15.In your opinion, what has been the CN's biggest failure?

a. Why do think this happened?

b. How did you deal with it?

16. In your opinion, what should be the main goal of the CN for the next year?

17. Please assess the long term financial stability of the network (Circle one)

Very Unstable Unstable






Stable Very Stable
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

a. What strategies is the Board pursuing to achieve sustainability? (List below)

1. In your opinion, what are the three greatest obstacles that the CN has to overcome to achieve sustainability?

2. What other revenue streams is the CN investigating?

3. What information would you need to help you investigate sustainability issues?

4. Who have you talked to in the community about sustainability for the CN?

b. When would you estimate that the network will achieve self-sufficiency?

c. Who have you approached about grants, matching funds, donations

1. Was the effort successful? Yes __ No __

18. What are the CN's revenues? Monthly ____ Quarterly ____

a. What are the sources of these revenues?

b. When do your contracts for T1 or modem pool access need to be renegotiated? _________

1. Do you expect the cost to increase or decrease?

2. Do you have plans to change who manages your server in the future? Yes __ No __

a. Why?

19.What do you charge for membership?

Individual members ________ Commercial members________ Non-profit members________

a. What do you get rebated back from the ISP per user?

20. Which of the following do you host on your CN (Check all that apply; if none apply, please skip to (d))?

__ Personal webpages for users __ Chat rooms/groups __ Pages for commercial or organizational members
__ Threaded discussions __ Local USENET newsgroups __ Listservs
__ Other USENET newsgroups

a. In your opinion, how satisfied are your users with these services?


Very Dissatisfied Neutral Very satisfied
Personal pages 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Commercial Org. Pages 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Local USENET 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Other USENET 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Chat 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Threaded Discussions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Listservs 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

b. Do you mention these services in your advertising? Yes ___ No ___

c.What are the most heavily used resources/ services/pages of your CN?

__ Communication __ Community/organizational information __ Community calendar
__ Directory information __ Local school information __ User home pages
__ Other ( please describe:)

d. If you have none of these services, why did you decide not to host them?

f. What new features/content would you like to see on the CN?

21. Have there been any discussions about a policy regarding the issue of censorship? Yes ___ No ___

1. If yes, have you censored any personal or organizational pages? Yes ___ No ___

2. If yes, have you censored any messages/postings/pages? Yes ___ No ___

3. Please describe your censorship policy if it is not available on your web site.

D. ICNA

22. How satisfied are you with ICNA? (Circle one)

Very unsatisfied MoveMoveMoveMove!!! Neutral Very satisfied
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

22. Of ICNA's various activities, which ones do you support?

23. Of ICNA's various activities, which ones do you object to?

24. What would you like to see ICNA do for your CN in the next year?

25. What services would you like the ICNA to offer as benefits of membership?

E. Personal Information

26. How long have you been a Board member? ___

27. Gender M __ F __ Age ____

28. What is your occupation? _________________________

29. How would you assess your computer experience?

Novice MoveMoveMoveMove MoveMoveMove!!!Intermediate Expert
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

30. How would you assess your internet experience?

Novice MoveMoveMoveMove MoveMoveMove!!!Intermediate Expert
1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Thank you very much for participating in this survey

Use the enclosed envelope to return the survey to:

Howard Rosenbaum
Mail Library 011
School of Library and Information Science
Bloomington, IN 47405-1801


You can fax the completed survey to:

Howard Rosenbaum
812.855.8166


Use this tool to move to any other section of the report or back to the Table of Contents. Select a section and press "GO!"

This page prepared by Howard Rosenbaum
Last update: 12.1.98
hrosenba@indiana.edu
You are here: http://memex.lib.indiana.edu/hrosenba/www/research/commnet/interview.html